Print This Print This

Posted on June 26th, 2007 in News, Politics, True Crime

Siegelman-Scrushy Sentencing: Day 1

By Kyle Whitmire

SiegelmanThe sentencing hearing for former Alabama Gov. Don Siegelman and former HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy began Tuesday morning, with the proceeding expected to last for as long as four days.

Before the hearing began, Scrushy, his family and several ministers prayed in a parking lot across the street from the Frank M. Johnson federal courthouse, and both defendants again proclaimed their innocence to the charges. Police had to separate and disperse protestors in front of the courthouse after a shouting match erupted among them.

Richard ScrushyAlmost one year ago, a federal jury in Montgomery found Scrushy and Siegelman guilty on charges of bribery, conspiracy and mail fraud. Siegelman was convicted also on an additional charge of obstruction of justice. According to prosecutors, Scrushy arranged a total $500,000 to pay down debt on Siegelman’s failed 1999 lottery campaign. Siegelman had personally secured the debt and would have had to pay the money himself had not someone else done so. In exchange, Siegelman appointed Scrushy to the Certificate of Needs board, a state agency that regulates hospitals and healthcare providers.

The sentencing follows a year of bizarre post-trial and pre-sentencing issues, as the defendants have accused jurors of improper communications before deliberations, requested the judge recuse himself because of a conflict of interest and accused state and national Republicans of trapping the defendants in a political conspiracy orchestrated by Karl Rove.

Prosecutors have asked that Scrushy and Siegelman be given 25 and 30 years in prison, respectively. Conversely, defense attorneys have asked that they be given probation. U.S. District Judge will split the difference when he pronounces a sentence later this week.

Also, Judge Fuller must determine whether to allow the defendants out on bond or to jail them after sentencing. Prosecutors have subpoenaed at least one witness, Scrushy’s yacht captain, and they are expected to argue the defendants should be taken into custody immediately after the sentence is handed down.

Tuesday morning, the attorneys argued how the defendants should fall on the federal sentencing guidelines, a complex and convoluted formula used for meting out punishments in federal criminal cases. The guidelines are only advisory for judges but they can be useful when contesting a sentence on appeal.

This morning, defense attorneys have argued that offenses on which the defendants were acquitted should not be considered when deciding the sentence. The law allows for judges to consider acquitted charges if they are relevant to the convictions and if the judge deems a preponderance of the evidence at trial supported the charges.

Check back for regular updates.

— Kyle Whitmire

  • Share/Bookmark
blog comments powered by Disqus

WEEKLY PICKS: do more now

Weekly Tweets

  • @blakebritton Patrick Cooper's twitter appears to be @PatCoop but he hasn't tweeted since June. #bham 2 days ago
  • Patrick Cooper is running for Mayor of Birmingham, has a three-point plan. Not "Let's Do Something." http://bit.ly/42EgLb 2 days ago
  • Story and Video: Smitherman terminates Langford chief of staff http://bit.ly/3VoUQS 2 days ago
  • Smitherman names Kevin Moore interim chief of staff. #bham 2 days ago
  • Presser over. 2 days ago
  • Says he's committed to the city. Ready to work hard, etc. Smitherman talking. Paepcke asks if any charges pressed against Bowie. No. #bham 2 days ago
  • But seriously folks, Mr. Moore last worked in Parks and Rec. He seems calm. Says this is a very important time for the city. #bham 2 days ago
  • He last worked in the Parks and Rec. dept, possibly under Leslie Knope. If you don't get it, google it. #bham 2 days ago
  • Moore has been associated with city hall in #bham for 14 years. Says there's a lot of work to be done. Going to work with budget and finance 2 days ago
  • Smitherman hopes to have proposals on how to fix the budget shortfall by Tuesday, says Moore is working through the weekend. #bham 2 days ago
  • Everyone is subject to review, smitherman says. #bham 2 days ago
  • Smitherman says she's been interviewing the Mayor's staff individually to find out who knew what about budget. #bham 2 days ago
  • More updates...

War on Dumb

The aftermath of Larry Langford 

The aftermath of Larry Langford 

Last week’s verdict established Larry Langford’s guilt, but it will be a long time before we’re done settling all his unanswered questions. 

Upon Further Review

Dear (New) Mayor, Let’s talk sports…

Dear (New) Mayor, Let’s talk sports…

Whoever emerges from the special election in December holding my city’s mantle of leadership inherits a sports scene that is in the direst of straits.

Column

The Ballad of Federal Gaol

The Ballad of Federal Gaol

A poem about an ex-mayor & a prisoner-to-be.

Film

Paranormal Activity yields big scares

Paranormal Activity yields big scares

Paranormal Activity builds scares out of shadows, loud noises and anticipation.

Small World Cartoons

Not My President

Not My President

When “your man” didn’t become President, what did you say?

(Click cartoon for a full size [...]

Suburban Legends

Batdance

Batdance

Some thoughts on the end of society