Print This Print This

Posted on October 7th, 2009 in War on Dumb

Birmingham City Council runoff rundown

By Kyle Whitmire

My Mobile friends have a joke about the weather there. It’s wonderful, they say. And if you don’t like it, wait 30 minutes and it will change. In Birmingham, we could have the same joke about our politics.

It’s a new day in Birmingham. And if you don’t like it, wait 24 hours and it will change.

Birmingham’s city council runoffs yielded a new, if mostly tweaked, council Tuesday night. Some of the biggest winners and losers weren’t even on the ballot.

Birmingham City Council President Carole Smitherman

Birmingham City Council President Carole Smitherman

The big winner Tuesday night was incumbent Council President Carole Smitherman.

Smitherman won with 51 percent of the District 6 vote. Typically, a margin that thin would reflect a weak incumbent and undercut her claim to higher office. It certainly doesn’t look like a mandate. But there are more factors to consider than that naked number.

Politics is the family business for Smitherman and her husband, Rodger the Senator, and they have accumulated fierce rivals. Virtually all of Smitherman’s enemies aligned against her, throwing their support to her opponent, Sheila Tyson.

Smitherman has run for mayor twice already, and it’s a fair assumption, she would try for the office again were Mayor Larry Langford convicted of corruption charges. For future opponents, this council race was an opportunity to kneecap the council president.

Tyson received support from some major personalities in Birmingham politics. Patrick Cooper supported Tyson, who served as his campaign manager two years ago. Former Birmingham Mayor Richard Arrington mailed a letter to District 6 voters saying that Tyson’s candidacy would factor strongly into his political future, too. (More on that further down.) Rep. John Rogers chipped in campaign funds for Tyson. Always coy but never bashful, Rogers said he had to support his cousin, Tyson, the same way Rodger Smitherman had to support his wife.

Smitherman’s opponents smelled blood in the water. The campaign was fierce and expensive.

“There is nothing quite as exhilarating as being shot at and missed,” Winston Churchill said. Smitherman must be feeling mighty exhilarated this week. She was shot at and missed more times than Gerald Ford and Inspector Clouseau combined. As a consequence, the attempts to tear her down could have backfired.

In any other reelection campaign, 51 percent would have been an embarrassment, but the assault against Smitherman makes the results Tuesday look like a hard-won victory. She didn’t just beat Tyson. She beat Cooper, Arrington and Rogers, too. If Smitherman is to stand a chance in a special election for mayor, she needed a boost. Her opponents gave it to her.

Elsewhere in the city, District 2 incumbent Carol Duncan ran the kind of race Mayor Bernard Kincaid ran two years ago. She filed her paperwork with the probate office, but otherwise, the spirit wasn’t there. During the last two years, Duncan has rolled over for Langford’s fast and loose proposals, realizing only after the fact that some of her pet issues, specifically transit, had been screwed by the fine print.

When Duncan first ran for office eight years ago, she told me then that she believed in term limits. Two terms, max, she said. On Tuesday night, her constituents held her to that promise.

Backed by a ragtag crew of libertarians and neighborhood leaders, Kim Rafferty ran an enthusiastic race against an incumbent who was embattled if not beaten already. She will hate the comparison, but there is much to her campaign and her approach to the office that reminds me of Duncan eight years ago. That’s not a bad thing, just a warning of what the future could hold for her if she isn’t careful.

In District 5, Johnathan Austin defeated Elias Hendricks after a long election-night back-and-forth. Until the last box came in, neither had a clear lead over the other.

For Hendricks, it was his third attempt at the office and his second loss. The former councilor never fully understood or appreciated the importance of neighborhood leaders’ support, and again, it cost him. With a few key endorsements, this race could have gone the other way for Hendricks. It didn’t.

Instead, key neighborhood leaders, former opponents and Councilor-turned-County Commissioner William Bell all endorsed Austin. It gave Austin the edge he needed to win.

Austin was appointed to fill Bell’s unexpired term. He was a compromise appointment, who was tarnished soon afterward by questions about his résumé and arrest record. However, Austin said something to me a few months ago that proved prescient. He told me he’d gotten all the dirty laundry out of the way the first few weeks in office. He was right, and Tuesday night, that helped him.

This election gives Austin legitimacy on the council he lacked until now. He might have been an appointee before, but Tuesday he won the backing of District 5 voters. The seat is his in his own right.

In District 7, Jay Roberson finished the race he nearly won six weeks ago. Most people I know who know Roberson feel comfortable with him on the council. Next to other council races, this one was among the more civil.

Roberson’s opponent, Ernestine Williams, showed she wasn’t ready for the office last month, when she told the Birmingham News that she had accepted in-kind campaign contributions from a donor who wanted to remain anonymous. Anonymous donations are OK if you’re giving to charity, but in politics, they’re illegal (unless, of course, you hide behind a PAC). Regardless, the best candidate seems to have won, and District 7 finally has a representative to fill Miriam Witherspoon’s vacant seat.

In Disctrict 9, incumbent Roderick Royal defeated Leroy Bandy for the third time. On election night, he told the Birmingham News that his victory was over boss politics. He was talking, of course, about Bandy’s support from former Mayor Arrington.

If there was a clear loser Tuesday night, it was Arrington. He supported Sheila Tyson. Tyson lost. He supported Elias Hendricks. Hendricks lost. He supported Leroy Bandy. Bandy lost. Arrington has predicated a return to Birmingham politics on the success of these endorsements. Indeed, the old machine-style politics failed. It’s a new day in Birmingham. And if you don’t like it, wait 24 hours and it will change.

War on Dumb is a column about political culture. Write to kyle@bhamweekly.com

  • Share/Bookmark
  • In District 2, the difference is that Kim Rafferty is not a politician, but a true servant. Kim Rafferty has the mind of an intellectual, the grit of a Marine, the grace of a lady, but the heart of a servant.
    I predict that Kim Rafferty will be noted as one of the outstanding city councilors in Birmingham's history.
  • Kyle, I think you might have said 'diverse.' Also, echoing a comment made by Stephen Gordon, it was a civil campaign.

    What can we do to increase civility among officials and ourselves?
  • Helen, thank you for your defense. However, I kinda like being designated as "ragtag".
    Kim Rafferty's effort certainly had friends in low places!
    Glad to support Kim Rafferty, destined to be one of the finest councilors in the history of Birmingham
  • Ragtag was meant as a term of affection, of course. Although, I must insist that once someone files their papers and pays their fees with probate, then like it or not, he or she is a "politician." Not that there's anything wrong with that (to borrow a line from Seinfeld).
  • geneedelman
    pooper scooper cooper wants how weird ball less to be kims assisant one termer for shure
  • geneedelman
    how weird ball less as anass sis tant will make kim a one termer
  • geneedelman
    here come how weird ball less kim will be a one termer
    d
  • geneedelman
    pooper scooper cooper looses again
  • Anyone who knows KIM RAFFERTY knows that she is a strong and independent woman who will make her own decisions.
  • Stephen Gordon
    Kyle,

    If you happen to head down to The Garage, those "ragtag" libertarians left you a present with the cashier. Nope, not a dead feline, but something more appropriate for your snark. :)
  • Uh-oh.
  • mimo814
    Kyle -- loved the assessment of the Dist. 6 race, and you are absolutely RIGHT! It was a big wake up call for Arrington just to go ahead and stay in Hoover, and for Patrick Cooper to either step up the game and explain himself and his views, or move on; there's too much ambiguity around him, and voters on this side of town felt the disconnect. Also -- Word on the western-area streets is that John Rogers is not related to Tyson at all...and it was just a cover for him to endorse her, in exchange for support for his run for Rodger Smitherman's Senate seat (in the event she were to win -- HA!).

    I know Ms. Smitherman, she is an excellent councillor, I hope she makes a remarkalbe interim mayor, and I'm going to work hard to help her become the people's choice should she decide to run.
blog comments powered by Disqus

WEEKLY PICKS: do more now

  • FRIDAY, NOV. 20

    FRIDAY, NOV. 20

    GREEK MYTHOLOGY FOR THE MODERN AGE: To review: Eurydice was ...

  • SATURDAY, NOV. 21

    SATURDAY, NOV. 21

    REQUIEM FOR A SCHEME: The featured composition at Saturday’s Alabama ...

  • SUNDAY, NOV. 22

    SUNDAY, NOV. 22

    BLAZE THE TRAIL: Or, at the very least, help trim ...

Weekly Tweets

  • Can Jefferson County break the bank? The meaning of Jefferson County's suit against banking behemoth JPMorgan: http://bit.ly/2JfcKk #bham 7 hrs ago
  • @WadeOnTweets I don't see Dr. Davis on Twitter any time soon. We're plugging your blogging academy classes in next week's Weekly Picks btw. 1 day ago
  • Nice to see @bhamterminal 's @acnatta on Fox6 w BSC's Natalie Davis discussing #bham mayoral race. Video @WadeOnTweets: http://bit.ly/1o93gZ 1 day ago
  • @brightsides Thanks for comments on last week's cover. It was designed by Jeremy Markham (http://bit.ly/1l7Yx1). More: http://bit.ly/4bvRoK 1 day ago
  • Forest Perk Coffee opened today--new coffee shop on Clairmont (next to Piggly Wiggly). Just went by there--the coffee's good. Check it out. 1 day ago
  • Shout out to @DNicholAdams for her tweeting of the #bham mayoral forum tonight. She did a great job. Thanks for the live feed! 2 days ago
  • Also slated to appear: William Jason Sumner (?) & Jimmy Snow. No Smitherman or Hoyt? Election Dec. 8. Educate yourselves. We'll help. #bham 3 days ago
  • Mayoral forum information came from Delta Sigma Theta Alum association, who is putting on forum and was kind enough to call me back. #bham 3 days ago
  • William Bell, Patrick Cooper, Emory Anthony, Scott Douglas, Stephannie Huey, Jody Trautwein and others coming to #bham mayoral forum tonight 3 days ago
  • Don't forget there's a mayoral forum tonight at 6:30 p.m. at Huffman High, and a meet & greet Thursday at Highland Hotel, 5-7 p.m. #bham 3 days ago
  • I think if you count the fact that council started about 30 minutes late, this may be the quickest council meeting I've ever seen. #bham 3 days ago
  • Council meeting over except for old & new business. Hoyt says he is the fried turkey king, and will fry turkeys when done w/ politics #bham 3 days ago
  • More updates...

War on Dumb

Can Jefferson County break the bank?

Can Jefferson County break the bank?

Jefferson County has declared war on JPMorgan.

Upon Further Review

Lane Kiffin’s (allegedly) lost boys

Lane Kiffin’s (allegedly) lost boys

Lane Kiffin’s players are undisciplined? You don’t say…

Column

Surviving the New Depression with sweet taters

Surviving the New Depression with sweet taters

Political commentary plus a recipe for sweet potato pie.

Film

2012 blows up the world real good

2012 blows up the world real good

2012 may be the hugest, craziest, most preposterous disaster film ever made

Small World Cartoons

Jobless Recovery

Jobless Recovery

Things are looking up for the economy! Or they’re not.

(Click cartoon for a full size [...]

Suburban Legends

The Wedding Planner

A classic from the Suburban Legends Vault